Unfortunately, it has neither the my book elites eink display nor the essentials capacity gauge. Hey op wanted to give you some more info on the seagate personal cloud, as well as our other home storage and backup devicessolutions. May 07, 2014 the seagate backup plus fast and western digital my passport pro are the two such 4tb portable external hard disk drives that we are taking a closer look at today and despite the fact that they both offer 4tb of storage capacity, they are actually very different drives in terms of their design, size, specifications, and features. My book desktop storage also works great with acronis true image wd edition software to schedule complete system backups. Compare seagate 4tb backup plus portable hard drive vs wd 4tb my book desktop usb 3. I reckoned that id gotten a faulty drive and asked for a replacement, which behaved. The 8tb version of the western digital my book is a deep well of affordable. I have a spare wd mybook enclosure and a spare 500gb seagate sata drive. By contrast, the best seagate can muster is 10tb of storage from the singledrive backup plus hub amazon or expansion desktop. Jul 29, 2014 the good the wd my book duo has plenty of storage space, fast performance, hardware raid, and a builtin twoport usb 3.
Equipped with wd backup software for windows and apple time machine compatibility for mac, the my book desktop hard drive can back up your photos, videos, music and documents. The seagate backup plus portable is the reserved cousin of the western digital my book. Just recently, both seagate and western digital announced new 4tb portable external hard disk drives, and these drives are true portable hard disk drives in the sense that they do not need to connect to an external power source. So this is the most important reason people choose seagate backup plus slim. Apr 21, 2020 both seagate and western digital offer pocket external hard drives with different capacities and connectivity. The best external hard drives for 2020 digital trends. Thinking the enclosure was bad, i put in a wd drive to test it and it mounts just fine. Another difference is my passport ultra is usbc ready, usb 3. The best external hard drives you can buy in 2020 the telegraph. Mar 19, 2017 hey op wanted to give you some more info on the seagate personal cloud, as well as our other home storage and backup devicessolutions. Both are able to store documents, however, you may prefer the wd my passport if you want to store important documents. Seagate backup plus slim is a very popular option at the bottom of the price range. Get it today with same day delivery, order pickup or drive up.
It seems that when i put that drive in the mybook enclosure it does not mount. The wd mybook duo range builds up from 3 tb to 24 tb, with superfast. While you have to reformat my passport into compatible file format in order to use it on. Feb 28, 2017 the my book comes with a threeyear warranty, longer than the two years you get with the seagate backup plus.
However, seagate drives come in both cheaper and faster, though only. It is 1st ranked while wd my passport is in 4th rank by the slant community. The personal cloud is all yours, at home and secure. Nov 12, 2019 the wd element and the wd my passport are ideal for transferring and storing photos, videos, and music. Wd my book is a very popular and one of the more expensive options. My computer and my laptop and my office computer recognizes my book for about 5 seconds and then dosent for 5 seconds then does etc etc etc. Seagate backup plus slim was released last year in january. One of the most important things to keep in mind when picking a hard drive, or any kind of storage hardware for that matter is reliability. Plug in the seagate backup plus slim 2tb, which is formatted for mac right. I always use western digital drives for replacement parts. Put your digital life on the high capacity my book desktop hard drive with ultrafast usb 3. It isnt available in massive capacities, topping out at 5tb, but it comes with a more refined aesthetic. Mar 11, 20 better buy seagate backup plus 1 tb external hard disk black at rs. For one thing, you will find that the drive comes with a second device named western digital ses usb device.
I use a wd my book 1 tb external drive for time machine, which i picked over my passport because i leave it connected all the time and dont need the portability. While portability is not the western digital my books strong suit and it. Western digital wins out when it comes to larger capacities, offering its my book duo amazon with 20tb of storage in either a raid 0 or raid 1 configuration, along with plenty of connectivity. Compare seagate 4tb backup plus portable hard drive vs wd. This model lacks backup software, though, and it has a shorter. Wd mybook essential enclosure and non wd replacement drive. Seagate vs western digital what are the differences on. For the seagate expansion and backup plus, from what ive seen its a crapshoot whether or not youll get an smr drive or a barracuda, and well, you dont want an smr drive if you care at all about performance. We also use the same technology as online banking to help protect your files when you access from different devices. I installed the wd software bundled with the drive but i chose to not have it start with windows. The my book doesnt have extra usb ports to work as a usb hub, a cool feature first introduced by the seagate backup plus hub. Many reasons, but mainly it keeps too much information hidden, you cant easily manage the files it backs up, and it seems to provide full services only when you subscribe to their.
Dec 04, 2018 another difference is my passport ultra is usbc ready, usb 3. Seagate vs western digital what are the differences on storage. Store data safely on this 2tb western digital hard drive. Its in the top 3 bestselling external hard drives and has dozens of popular alternatives in the same price range, such as adata hd710 or wd my passport ultra 1tb seagate backup plus desktop was released in 2015. The wd my book duo is the absolute largest capacity external hard drive. Wd my book essentials 3tb posted in external hardware. But modern ones are faster, more stylish, and often more durable than their. That said, the dualdrive versions are pretty expensive, with. Oct 24, 2017 pc must be on or in standby mode\r\rseagate backup plus slim portable drive\r\rbe ready. The 8 tb wd easystore was faster than both models by about two minutes. Everyday performance i tested the my book on both a mac and a windows pc. The 2tb drive that i thought was done is now connected to my laptop and amazingly still working just fine. It has dozens of popular alternatives in the same price range, such as wd my book or wd my passport wireless pro. Although the casing is bulky on wd the durability is questionable as its little flimsy and brittle.
Oct 11, 2016 the my book doesnt have extra usb ports to work as a usb hub, a cool feature first introduced by the seagate backup plus hub. I reckoned that id gotten a faulty drive and asked for a replacement, which behaved the same way. My question is that it seems as if i can only put a wd drive in the mybook enclosure. The western digital my book does feature a few twists though. Wd my passport ultra vs seagate backup plus slim vs toshiba vs hgst vs samsung january 1, 2015 storage hdd, portable, usb3 pretzel it is this authors opinion that 2015 should be the year of the backup. Nov 14, 2011 wd my book essential 3tb brief description performance wise, the wd my book essential is not excellent and there are faster external drives in the market. You want one thats fast, easy to use, and wont break the bank. Seagate backup plus desktop is a very popular option in the middle of the external hard drives price range. If you are considering purchasing an external hard drive, the following seagate western digital is worth buying. I do have a 3tb seagate though since the external update and its worked as expected. I see a lot more failed seagate drives than western digital drives. Pc must be on or in standby mode\r\rseagate backup plus slim portable drive\r\rbe ready. One of the best features of any pclaptop is drag and drop. Which external hard drive is better, seagate or wd elements, and.
Western digital my passport ultra 4tb external hard drive. Wd smartware automatic backup software and password protection with hardware encryption ensure your data is protected. I broke my wd passport drive just in couple of dropshdd is still functional but outer case is broken. Its been working great for over half a year and ive had no problems so far. And like all desktop external hard drive, the my book require an. Wd my book essential 3tb brief description performance wise, the wd my book essential is not excellent and there are faster external drives in the. Ultrafast transfer rates when connected to a usb 3.
The good the wd my book duo has plenty of storage space, fast performance, hardware raid, and a builtin twoport usb 3. The external storage device is also affordable, and allows you to. With the power of wd backup, time machine compatibility and acronis true image wd edition software, youve got complete backup routine options to help recover data in the event of a computer virus, computer failure, or if. Wd my passport essential 1 tb as time machine backup. The most important reason people chose seagate backup plus slim is. The 8 tb wd my book was about as fast as the 8 tb seagate in our time machine backup test. The my book desktop hard drive also works great with acronis true image wd edition software to schedule full system backups. Its fast 540 mbs read and write speeds are more than enough to transfer any file.
Slow external hard drives seagate backup plus and wd my book. Both seagate and western digital offer pocket external hard drives with different capacities and connectivity. That just goes to show that wd my book external drives are truly workhorses that give you years of use. The mammoth 8tb capacity on the wd 8tb my book is the largest i have seen to date of this size in terms of dimension, as it measures only 170mm by 140mm. May 24, 2017 the mammoth 8tb capacity on the wd 8tb my book is the largest i have seen to date of this size in terms of dimension, as it measures only 170mm by 140mm.
Seagate backup plus slim is ranked 1st while wd my passport is ranked 4th. Wd 8tb usb my book vs seagate 8tb backup plus hub pc storage. The wd my passport vs the seagate backup plus vs the toshiba canvio. When it comes to storage, western digital and seagate are perhaps the two most. My passport range amazon, though seagates backup plus portable drives. Slow external hard drives seagate backup plus and wd my. Seagate expansion or wd mybook for external hard drive. The my book comes with a threeyear warranty, longer than the two years you get with the seagate backup plus. Wd mycloud vs seagate personnal cloud vs other home nas.
The seagate backup plus fast and western digital my passport pro are the. The singledrive my book tops out at western digital my book, which, for 10tb of storage, is a crazy good deal. The seagate backup plus desktop drive combines speed and capacity. I honestly doubt theres a difference as theyre relatively the same price usually. Its wd backup software automatically saves files on a preset schedule, and it has a sleek but durable design for portability without sacrificing security. Which is the best external hard drive, seagate or wd. Seagate expansion vs seagate backup plus hub vs wd.
Better buy seagate backup plus 1 tb external hard disk black at rs. This device requests the installation of drivers which can be found on windows update or on the drive itself. Based on 495,302 user benchmarks for the seagate barracuda 2016 and the wd blue 2015, we rank them both on effective speed and value for money against the best 1,015 hdds. My book external hard drive ultrafast backup and storage. It also includes with ntfs driver for macos so you can work on macos operating system without reformatting. Among those external drives, western digitals my passport series and seagate s backup plus portable drives are popular. If you are considering purchasing an external hard drive, the following seagatewestern digital is worth buying. The seagate backup plus fast and western digital my passport pro are the two such 4tb portable external hard disk drives that we are taking a closer look at today and despite the fact that they both offer 4tb of storage capacity, they are actually very different drives in terms of their design, size, specifications, and features. The wd my passport vs the seagate backup plus vs the toshiba.
The drive that arrived another backup plus was exceedingly slow during data transfers. Seagates smaller drives are reliable and speedy and offer great value for money. Its in the top 3 bestselling external hard drives and has dozens of popular alternatives in the same price range, such as lacie rugged mini or silicon power 2tb a60. Which is best external hard disk drive available in the market. Ive had a western digital my book 4 tb external backup drive for about a year and a half and im not happy with it. Among those external drives, western digitals my passport series and seagates backup plus portable drives are popular. The wd element and the wd my passport are ideal for transferring and storing photos, videos, and music. Since the my passport pro was designed for use with macs, we used a late 20 15inch macbook pro.
644 682 1112 1314 498 745 246 1083 1449 1476 1301 717 12 1523 1179 235 248 973 600 361 388 385 593 742 593 1015 655 1020 1451 647 983 1006 753 728 52 158